top of page
Search

Beyond the data

Writer: Dr Beatrice Hayes
Dr Beatrice Hayes
Nov 5
5 min read

Updated: Nov 11

Dr Beatrice Hayes considers how we can increase our understanding of what shapes pupils' experiences.



When you reflect upon your school’s pupil profile, what stands out? You may draw upon demographic patterns such as the socioeconomic background of your catchment areas, or perhaps you consider behavioural patterns such as common mental health needs. No matter what springs to mind, you are drawing upon some form of data.


Quantitative data refers to numerical and reportable facts and figures. Qualitative data refers to more nuanced often text or experience-based information. We draw upon these types of data to make conclusions, and this applies to how we think about our pupils and their experience of school.


The Department for Education highlights the importance of utilising data to inform evidence-based decisions. Modern educational policies are increasingly emphasising the need to gather more extensive data to further understand the reasoning behind certain patterns we see. When collecting data, such as attendance or attainment, we are able to understand the ‘what’ but this type of data does not tell us the ‘why’.


Modern educational policies are increasingly emphasising the need to gather more extensive data to further understand the reasoning behind certain patterns we see.

Staff tend to rely on qualitative data such as anecdotal information to fill the gaps behind the quantitative data. Anecdotal information is useful and important for ensuring contextual nuances, but it is often influenced by human errors such as biases and misinterpretation.


To better understand the data we collect about our pupils and consider how we can best incorporate this within practice, we must prioritise developing our understanding of the pupils’ psychology behind the data.


Understanding what drives engagement


One important theme running through much of the data collected in schools is pupil engagement.


What extent pupils engage with school is strongly predictive of how successful their overall learning experience will be. We understand student engagement at school as ‘the extent to which a student values school-related outcomes and identifies and participates in academic and non-academic activities’ (Willms, 2003, as cited in Alrashidi et al., 2016), but how often do staff consider what feeds into pupils’ engagement?


What extent pupils engage with school is strongly predictive of how successful their overall learning experience will be.

According to Self-Determination Theory (SDT; Ryan, 2000), feelings of autonomy, competence, and relatedness are crucial for enhancing engagement.


With this in mind, if we are collecting data on engagement but failing to capture information on these underpinnings, we are missing important foundational knowledge about our pupils’ engagement.


Building a fuller picture provides greater understanding of engagement data in a way that can benefit future thinking and forward planning; this can facilitate a proactive rather than reactive approach to managing pupils’ engagement at school.


Belonging and connectedness: similar but different


How can we capture this information? Several psychological constructs, including belonging, connectedness, self-esteem and self-efficacy, can help us explore aspects of pupils' experiences associated with engagement. Although similar, these constructs have important differences that can help us to understand the complexity of pupil engagement.


  • Belongingness refers to feeling attached to the school community, being valued by others , and incorporating this within one’s sense of identity (Baumeister & Leary, 1995; Willms, 2000).


  • Connectedness refers to the strength of the social networks that exist between individuals in the school (Blum, 2005).


Let’s apply this to the context of pupils:


Hannah and Fatima are both Y9 girls who have increasingly been noted as absent from P.E. classes. Based on the attendance data alone, their P.E. teacher may apply an identical approach to managing this non-attendance or draw upon anecdotal data to differentiate approaches. However, if their P.E. teacher drew upon an SDT approach, they may discover that Hannah has a high sense of belonging – she feels a part of the school community and is proud to be a pupil there – but she has a low sense of connectedness – none of her friends are in the same P.E. class and she does not tend to engage with the P.E. department in general.


Fatima, on the other hand, may have a high sense of connectedness – she has lots of friends in the P.E. class and the P.E. teacher is her form tutor whom she likes – but she has low belongingness – she is the only girl in her class who wears a hijab and feels her identity misaligns with her peers.


Drawing upon these insights, the underlying constructs of engagement are quite different for both Hannah and Fatima. Although their engagement data is similar, they need different approaches to support their future engagement.


Self-esteem and self-efficacy: why the distinction matters


The differences between self-esteem and self-efficacy are also important to consider.


  • Self-esteem is the overall evaluation of the self (Rosenberg, 1965)

  • Self-efficacy is a person’s belief in their capability to achieve goals (Bandura & Wessels, 1997).


Let’s apply this again to two fictional pupils.


Thomas and Hassim are both Y11 boys receiving after school tutoring to support preparation for GCSE English. Their attainment data suggests that Thomas’ overall performance is improving quicker than Hassim’s.


Drawing upon this data alone, it could be surmised that Thomas no longer requires these sessions. However, if a SDT approach was adopted, it could be identified that Thomas has high self-efficacy – he feels able to complete the work in the sessions to the best of his ability – but low self-esteem – he does not believe he is an academic person.


Hassim, on the other hand, has low self-efficacy – he doesn’t believe that he has the skills to complete the work in the sessions – but he has high self-esteem – he believes that he is generally successful at ‘figuring things out in life’.


With this knowledge, Thomas absolutely should remain attending the sessions and the goals for these sessions should be differentiated.


From data to insight


Importantly, if we considered only the overall data across these pupils, we would be missing crucial differences in what lies beneath their behaviour. Our Pupil Insights service provides a valuable starting point for exploring the ‘why’ behind the patterns we typically observe in school data.


Drawing upon scientifically valid tools, Pupil Insights allows us to to delve deeper into our pupils’ behaviour, building a more accurate and nuanced picture. Using this, we can use resources more effectively to create more proactive approaches to supporting students’ engagement. When asked about your pupils in the future, you can pair Pupil Insights with pre-existing school data to paint a far more reliable and accurate picture.


Take a look at our surveys and how they work and can help you in the classroom.



 
 
 

Comments


All surveys comply with UK GDPR; data are anonymised and aggregated.

​​

© 2026 Pupil Insights, part of Greenshaw Research School

bottom of page